Lowell Libson & Jonny Yarker Ltd

  • Pencil
  • 7 ½ × 5 ½ inches · 190 × 143 mm
  • Drawn c. 1757

Collections

  • The artist’s posthumous sale, London, Christie’s 11 May 1799, lot 82, 84 or 88 (to Hibbert);
  • George Hibbert (1757-1837), Munden House, Hertfordshire, by descent;
  • Hon. A H. Holland Hibbert (1855-1935);
  • Holland-Hibbert sale, Christie’s, 30 June 1913, probably lot 32 - Tree Studies - a pair 7 x 5 1/4 inches, (bt Leggatt £3.3s); 
  • H.W. Underdown;
  • John Manning, Manning Galleries, (as Constable);
  • A. C. Greg, Acton Bridge, acquired from the above;
  • Sotheby’s, 24 September 1987, lot 65;
  • With Richard Ivor;
  • John Bull;
  • John Bull sale, Sotheby’s, 16 July 1992, lot 110;
  • Private collection, acquired from the above, to 2018

Literature

  • John Hayes, The Drawings of Thomas Gainsborough, London, 1970, vol. I, pp. 3,152, cat. no. 173;
  • Ian Fleming-Williams, Constable and his Drawings, London, 1990, pp.54-55, fig. 50.

This rapidly executed pencil study of a clump of trees was made by Gainsborough whilst he was still in his native Suffolk at the end of the 1750s. Gainsborough’s friend and obituarist, the Reverend Sir Henry Bate Dudley wrote in 1788 that: ‘Nature was his teacher and the woods of Suffolk his academy; here he would pass in solitude his moments in making a sketch of an antiquated tree, a marshy brook, a few cattle, a sheep herd and his flock, or any other accidental objects that were present.’[1] 

This drawing identical in size to a number of comparable sheets of the same period which are also focused plein air studies and it was almost certainly part of a now dismembered sketchbook. According to Joseph Farington a group of sketchbooks were sold by the artist’s daughter Margaret in 1799 for £140.3s.6d.[2] Of the ten books offered for sale at Christie’s, three were acquired by the West India merchant and collector George Hibbert, one by the collector and connoisseur Richard Payne Knight, one bought in half-shares by Hibbert and Sir George Beaumont, one was acquired by the dealers Colnaghi’s and ‘Mr Pugh’, the artist Hugh Pugh, also bought three.[3] The present sheet comes from one of the Hibbert sketchbooks.

The purpose of such studies was clearly to inform Gainsborough’s own practice as a landscape painter. The close observation of clumps of tree allowed him to understand the construction of the plant, the massing of lights and shadows and the way the foliage behaved in different weather and seasons. Gainsborough was clearly working out a method of hatching which could suggest the characteristics of the tree without drawing every leaf, a method which was informed at this date by his interest in Dutch landscape painting of the seventeenth century. In another sheet, of precisely the same format, Gainsborough records a similar contrast in the form between two trees — the nearest shows strong light touching the left hand side of the tree and on the other side Gainsborough uses thick black chalk to show the foliage.[4] These sheets ultimately informed Gainsborough’s practice as a landscape painter, but rather than providing templates from which he could quote in his paintings, they acted as exercises, allowing him to work out a method of drawing individual trees back in his studio. Gainsborough articulated the idea that these studies acted as exercises rather than formal drawings in a letter to his patron, Constantine Phipps, who he was teaching to draw:

You know, Sir, I set you to this [sketch of foliage] merely to free your hand, but you are not to understand that for Drawing – therefore remember that there must be truth of hand, as well as freedom of hand in Drawing.[5]

References

  1. The Morning Herald, 8 August, 1788. 
  2. Ed. Kenneth Garlick and Angus Macintyre, The Diary of Joseph Farington, New Haven and London, 1979, IV, p.1222.
  3. John Hayes, The Drawings of Thomas Gainsborough, London, 1970, I, p.96. 
  4. John Hayes, The Drawings to Thomas Gainsborough, London 1970, I, pp.151, cat. nos. 168, 172, pls. 56 and 386.
  5. Thomas Gainsborough to the Hon Constantine Phipps, later 2nd Baron Mulgrave, in ed. John Hayes, The Letters of Thomas Gainsborough, New Haven and London, 2001, p.92.